Madison vs. Marshall :: essays research papers

Before we start to take sides, we need to discuss the different tiptop of views of capital of Wisconsin and Marshall. We have to understand that our political landscape during the birth of our demesne was much different. The states, were not unified, and were made up of different and often opposed interests. Along with factions fighting one another and making political advance impossible. As Madison, would describe faction as a number of citizens whether it be a legal age or minority whole, who were motivate by whatsoever common impulse of passion or of interest. This broad definition would let in the interest groups who dominate the political landscape today. In Madisons work of Federalist No. 10, he identifies factions were a problem. He views them as a dangerous vice, but at the same time see factions as a necessary evil. He mentions that The regulation of these various and meddlesome interest forms the principal task of modern legislation and involves the spirit of ship s company and faction in the necessary and ordinary operations of government. Here Madison states that factions, opposed in spirit to democratic ideals, spreading unsteadiness and darkness which are actually necessary for the function of a representative government. throughout his paper, Madison explains how pure democracy wouldnt be able to work, because it had no cure for the mischief of faction. He believed that this type of government will course so much power to the majority that it was doomed to fail. He sounded actually confident that the unseasoned constitution would work. He believed of having a representative and a republic system. He had no doubt in mind that new constitution would be the end of the states embarrassment to the world. Madison saw democracy not as an ideal but something that could be modified to be fitted.Two hundreds years later Thurgood Marshall verbalize that Constitution scripted by our Founding Fathers was a defect from the start. As he said the first three words of the Constitution says We the People was a flaw. At the time our Founding Fathers didnt have in mind the majority of Americans. The only thing on their mind was the wealthy population. Also he states how some things they wrote wasnt place in action years later. For instance all humans are created equal. This was a defect it took an amendment to make this in effect. But Madison did say he couldnt foresee the time to come of the government to the effects it could have.